About the Research
The idea for this research project emerged in the fall of 2023, when a student with vision loss enrolled in a course that contained a significant number of educational images. Unsure how best to provide meaningful image descriptions, the department reached out to a member of our research team for assistance.
We began exploring generative artificial intelligence (AI) to create alternative text (alt-text) for these images. While AI offered a promising approach to improving access to educational materials, it also raised an important question:
Did the AI-generated image descriptions provide students with the information they needed to understand and engage with the images within their educational context?
This experience became the foundation for our research into the potential benefits and limitations of AI-generated alt-text in Humanities and Social Sciences education. Through this research, we hope to better understand how generative AI can create meaningful, educationally relevant image descriptions that support the learning needs of students with vision loss.
This research project has received approval from the McMaster Research Ethics Board (REB #7916).
Research Purpose and Objectives
This study explores the challenges and benefits that blind and low-vision students in higher education experience when using educational images and their associated alternative text (alt-text) in the Humanities and Social Sciences.
Research Objectives
- Identify challenges and benefits: Examine the challenges and benefits of AI-generated alt-text for blind and low-vision students studying in the Humanities and Social Sciences.
- Improve AI-generated alt-text: Explore ways to address the limitations of AI-generated alt-text and improve its accuracy, relevance, and usefulness for educational purposes.
- Develop educational resources: Create practical guides for students, faculty, and staff on using generative AI to produce meaningful and accessible alt-text for educational images in the Humanities and Social Sciences.
Who Can Participate?
We are seeking undergraduate and graduate students who are blind or have low vision and use a screen reader to access their course materials. Participants must be enrolled at an Ontario post-secondary institution and either be majoring in the Humanities or Social Sciences or taking courses in these disciplines.
We also welcome individuals who have graduated from an Ontario post-secondary institution within the past five years and met these criteria during their studies.
What Does Participation Involve?
Participation in this study involves two activities:
- A 90-minute online small-group interview conducted through Zoom between January 15 and 30, 2027, during which participants will discuss their experiences with alternative text (alt-text) and what makes image descriptions effective or ineffective.
- A follow-up survey conducted through Microsoft Forms in March 2027, in which participants will evaluate sample image descriptions. The survey will take approximately 30 minutes to complete.
As a thank-you for their time, participants will receive $50 in gift cards to a retailer of their choice, distributed in two installments: $25 after the group interview and $25 after completing the survey.
Participation is entirely voluntary. Participants may choose not to answer any question or discontinue their participation. Further information about participation and withdrawal will be provided in the research information letter.
Accessibility and Accommodation
We are committed to making all aspects of this research accessible. If you require accommodations to participate in the study or encounter accessibility barriers when completing the pre-screening questionnaire, please contact a member of our research team.
Research Results
This study is expected to be completed by the end of 2027. Participants may request a summary of the research findings and any published results in their preferred accessible format.
Interested in Participating?
Please complete the participant pre-screening questionnaire through Microsoft Teams by 31 December 2026. We will follow up with next steps for those selected.